[proposal] The open all repositories
hi all and tc members Today we discussed the private repositories management on community weekly-meeting. please refer to the log[1] we already get agreement on this meet that to open all other private repositories AQAP, I open this mail thread to get approval from the tc team. here are several reasons that should open them: 1. The governance encourage to open all, as the initial partner of this community, they should be open. 2. The privilege with public repositories and private repositories is quick different, that will make much efforts on managing them. other more, I would propose to not accept private repository any more. please review it, any comments are welcome. thanks. [1] http://meetings.openeuler.org/openeuler-meeting/2020/community/2020-01-14-02...
From: Edward Lee via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 11:14 AM To: tc@openeuler.org Subject: [Tc] [proposal] The open all repositories hi all and tc members Today we discussed the private repositories management on community weekly-meeting. please refer to the log[1] [Xinwei] Thanks for the log. But I went it through, and failed to understand the issue. Please give more details. i.e. list of private repos and what are they. we already get agreement on this meet that to open all other private repositories AQAP, I open this mail thread to get approval from the tc team. here are several reasons that should open them: 1. The governance encourage to open all, as the initial partner of this community, they should be open. [Xinwei] I think this is a political decision, which is right to be made by board. TC should focus on the technical side. 2. The privilege with public repositories and private repositories is quick different, that will make much efforts on managing them. [Xinwei] Could you give more details on the technical difficulty ? other more, I would propose to not accept private repository any more. please review it, any comments are welcome. thanks. [1] http://meetings.openeuler.org/openeuler-meeting/2020/community/2020-01-14-02...
Hi Xinwei, From [1] you can read how the repositories are managed. From [2] you can find the private repositories by searching the keyword private. [1] https://gitee.com/openeuler/community/issues/I17WWY?from=project-issue [2] https://gitee.com/openeuler/community/blob/master/repository/src-openeuler.y... Fred 李永乐 From: Huxinwei via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 15:43 To: Edward Lee <freesky.edward@gmail.com> Cc: tc@openeuler.org Subject: [Tc] Re: [proposal] The open all repositories From: Edward Lee via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 11:14 AM To: tc@openeuler.org<mailto:tc@openeuler.org> Subject: [Tc] [proposal] The open all repositories hi all and tc members Today we discussed the private repositories management on community weekly-meeting. please refer to the log[1] [Xinwei] Thanks for the log. But I went it through, and failed to understand the issue. Please give more details. i.e. list of private repos and what are they. we already get agreement on this meet that to open all other private repositories AQAP, I open this mail thread to get approval from the tc team. here are several reasons that should open them: 1. The governance encourage to open all, as the initial partner of this community, they should be open. [Xinwei] I think this is a political decision, which is right to be made by board. TC should focus on the technical side. 2. The privilege with public repositories and private repositories is quick different, that will make much efforts on managing them. [Xinwei] Could you give more details on the technical difficulty ? other more, I would propose to not accept private repository any more. please review it, any comments are welcome. thanks. [1] http://meetings.openeuler.org/openeuler-meeting/2020/community/2020-01-14-02...
Fred: Thanks and the links are helpful. I count 2312 repos and 982 of them are marked as public. These numbers give the impression that the private repos include software packages which are not ready for inclusion in openEuler _yet_. It’ll be helpful to get confirmation on that. On the other hand, I think it’s good to start a vote for that “all packages *included* in openEuler *must* be *publicly* maintained. “ Regards Xinwei From: Liyongle (Fred) via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 3:50 PM To: tc@openeuler.org Subject: [Tc] Re: [proposal] The open all repositories Hi Xinwei, From [1] you can read how the repositories are managed. From [2] you can find the private repositories by searching the keyword private. [1] https://gitee.com/openeuler/community/issues/I17WWY?from=project-issue [2] https://gitee.com/openeuler/community/blob/master/repository/src-openeuler.y... Fred 李永乐 From: Huxinwei via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 15:43 To: Edward Lee <freesky.edward@gmail.com<mailto:freesky.edward@gmail.com>> Cc: tc@openeuler.org<mailto:tc@openeuler.org> Subject: [Tc] Re: [proposal] The open all repositories From: Edward Lee via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 11:14 AM To: tc@openeuler.org<mailto:tc@openeuler.org> Subject: [Tc] [proposal] The open all repositories hi all and tc members Today we discussed the private repositories management on community weekly-meeting. please refer to the log[1] [Xinwei] Thanks for the log. But I went it through, and failed to understand the issue. Please give more details. i.e. list of private repos and what are they. we already get agreement on this meet that to open all other private repositories AQAP, I open this mail thread to get approval from the tc team. here are several reasons that should open them: 1. The governance encourage to open all, as the initial partner of this community, they should be open. [Xinwei] I think this is a political decision, which is right to be made by board. TC should focus on the technical side. 2. The privilege with public repositories and private repositories is quick different, that will make much efforts on managing them. [Xinwei] Could you give more details on the technical difficulty ? other more, I would propose to not accept private repository any more. please review it, any comments are welcome. thanks. [1] http://meetings.openeuler.org/openeuler-meeting/2020/community/2020-01-14-02...
hi, Xinwei Thanks so much for the response. please see my comments below in red.
*[Xinwei] Thanks for the log. But I went it through, and failed to understand the issue. Please give more details. i.e. list of private repos and what are they. * Currently, there are more than 2000+ repositories in src-openeuler( https://gitee.com/src-openeuler) which you can check from the repo definition file[1], but most of them are private repositories, the problems is openEuler community shouldn't have the responsibility to manage such large number of private resources. it should be open if it is ready, if not ready, the right way should be maintained by other places util it is ready. that's only my opinion.
*[Xinwei] I think this is a political decision, which is right to be made by board. TC should focus on the technical side.* As the governance charter descripted[2], TC is the team to approve the repository addition, if I understand correctly, this proposal is in the scope of tc team, please let me know if I misunderstand anything.
*> **[Xinwei] Could you give more details on the technical difficulty ?* sorry, I and infrastructure team don't know why these still have so many private repositories. from infrastructure team, private repository management will take much efforts, that isn't what we excepted. that's the reason why to propose this email. [1] https://gitee.com/openeuler/community/blob/master/repository/src-openeuler.y... [2] https://gitee.com/openeuler/community/blob/master/zh/technical-committee/gov... On Tue, Jan 14, 2020 at 3:43 PM Huxinwei <huxinwei@huawei.com> wrote:
*From:* Edward Lee via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] *Sent:* Tuesday, January 14, 2020 11:14 AM *To:* tc@openeuler.org *Subject:* [Tc] [proposal] The open all repositories
hi all and tc members
Today we discussed the private repositories management on community weekly-meeting. please refer to the log[1]
*[Xinwei] Thanks for the log. But I went it through, and failed to understand the issue. Please give more details. i.e. list of private repos and what are they. *
we already get agreement on this meet that to open all other private
repositories AQAP, I open this mail thread to get approval from the tc team. here are several reasons that should open them:
1. The governance encourage to open all, as the initial partner of this community, they should be open.
*[Xinwei] I think this is a political decision, which is right to be made by board. TC should focus on the technical side.*
2. The privilege with public repositories and private repositories is quick different, that will make much efforts on managing them.
*[Xinwei] Could you give more details on the technical difficulty ? *
other more, I would propose to not accept private repository any more. please review it, any comments are welcome. thanks.
[1] http://meetings.openeuler.org/openeuler-meeting/2020/community/2020-01-14-02...
-- Edward Lee ----------------------------------------------------------- Email: freesky-edward@gamil.com Phone: 0086-18200191386 Twitter: https://twitter.com/EdwardL0086 Address: Chengdu City, Sichuan Privince, China
Another shortcoming is that community members used to change private repositories quite frequently and non-seriously. I agree with the proposal, which is to stop creating new private repositories and to the current private repos soon. Regards Fred 李永乐 From: Edward Lee via Tc [mailto:tc@openeuler.org] Sent: Tuesday, January 14, 2020 11:14 To: tc@openeuler.org Subject: [Tc] [proposal] The open all repositories hi all and tc members Today we discussed the private repositories management on community weekly-meeting. please refer to the log[1] we already get agreement on this meet that to open all other private repositories AQAP, I open this mail thread to get approval from the tc team. here are several reasons that should open them: 1. The governance encourage to open all, as the initial partner of this community, they should be open. 2. The privilege with public repositories and private repositories is quick different, that will make much efforts on managing them. other more, I would propose to not accept private repository any more. please review it, any comments are welcome. thanks. [1] http://meetings.openeuler.org/openeuler-meeting/2020/community/2020-01-14-02...
participants (3)
-
Edward Lee -
Huxinwei -
Liyongle (Fred)